Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • JC
  • MR

    “The lady’s that work there treat u like family special shout out to lexi

  • SD

    “When You’re Doing The Right Thing By Having The Best Terms and Benefits of Insurance

  • “As of today we are going to be saving $2,213/yr on our auto policy (hopefully more in the near future)…Thanks to Jason he was very good with making sure we got the best discount possible and still kept our same coverage if not better. Jason you were Awesome. THANK YOU..I’m a happy customer!�

  • “Great company to work with. They will take great care of your insurance needs!

  • “My wife and I were married last year, and we wanted to combine our auto and homeowner policies to save money. We compared premiums with GEICO and Nationwide where we were already policyholders, and they couldn’t come close to matching the Erie policy we got with Corey Butler at E L Webster. We upgraded our coverage and reduced our annual premiums by over $500.

    Corey explained everything very thoroughly, and was able to give updated quotes until we felt absolutely comfortable with our coverage. The paperwork was all done electronically and was very fast and easy to take care of. They even coordinated the policy switch from our previous insurance companies to make sure we had no gaps in coverage and that we received the proper premium refunds. I would recommend Corey and E L Webster to anyone.

  • “Anyone looking for insurance out there! We have both auto and home and love them! :~)”

  • “Fantastic customer service at E L Webster Insurance Agency!”

  • SD

    “I’ve been working with Jacqueline Lovins for years now. She has always given me the best rate I could find, is always easy to reach and is incredibly sweet and helpful (even when you’re calling about for a new rate that you need within twenty minutes before the DMV shuts down). I started out with her some years ago and eventually moved to California. Unfortunately, she wasn’t able to give me insurance out there, so I went with Farmers… And their price hurt me. I ended moving to North Carolina, and am so grateful I’m within the range of Erie again and got her back as my agent. Kudos to you, Jacqueline! You’re great at what you do :)”

  • OB

    “A quick story – as a newly married couple, my wife asked that I check in with her insurance company, USAA, today since we’re getting her moved to my auto policy. So I spoke with a rep at USAA earlier and your rate was $500 better than their’s on the auto insurance even when factoring in discounts for also having homeowner’s, etc.

    I want to thank EL Webster for keeping my rates as competitive as possible. They are saving me money every year!”

  • AT

    “My wife and I were married last year, and we wanted to combine our auto and homeowner policies to save money. We compared premiums with GEICO and Nationwide where we were already policyholders, and they couldn’t come close to matching the Erie policy we got with Corey Butler at E L Webster. We upgraded our coverage and reduced our annual premiums by over $500.

    Corey explained everything very thoroughly and was able to give updated quotes until we felt absolutely comfortable with our coverage. The paperwork was all done electronically and was very fast and easy to take care of. They even coordinated the policy switch from our previous insurance companies to make sure we had no gaps in coverage and that we received the proper premium refunds. I would recommend Corey and E L Webster to anyone.”

  • CB

    “I was just recently in the market for new auto insurance and E L Webster really came through for me. My agent was Corey Butler and he was very helpful with comparing my rates and getting me the right coverage for the right price. Other companies couldn’t compare with the rates I was able to get with Erie. I would recommend EL Webster and Erie Insurance to everyone.”

  • NN

    “I was referred to this agency by a friend, the agent I was told to contact was Corey Butler. He answered right away when I called and the agent I was working with was very polite and knowledgeable. So far he has responded to all m emails promptly. When we were reviewing my old policy, the old auto company had me covered for the state minimum, which would have left me personally liable for any major accident. He was able to save me money on my home and car insurance, and even increased my coverage to a more reasonable level. Great company it seems. I am very happy with the level of service and price.”